Barbara Brancaccio
饰 Herself
Bill Ellis
饰 Himself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State
Dorothy D'Eletto
饰 Herself - Archivist & Researcher
Geraldo Rivera
饰 Himself - Reporter (archive footage)
Karen Schweiger
饰 Herself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother
David Navarro
饰 Himself - Former Newscaster
Donna Cutugno
饰 Herself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer
Ralph Aquino
饰 Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD
Bobby Jensen
饰 Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD
Ernie Anastos
饰 Himself - Reporter (archive footage)
Andre Rand
饰 Himself - Suspect
Jim Callaghan
饰 Himself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle
Jim Dolan
饰 Himself - Reporter (archive footage)
Theresa Doyle
饰 Herself - Searcher for Jennifer
Ed Armstrong
饰 Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother
Sean Hughes
饰 Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage)
Peter Hughes
饰 Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Father
Holly Cederholm
饰 Herself - Holly Ann Hughes's Mother
Ken Schweiger
饰 Himself - Jennifer Schweiger's Father
